There Is Risk Of ‘Double Recovery’ In Personal Injury Cases, Says Local Attorney

North Carolina Supreme Court held that uninsured/underinsured benefits received by a car accident victim may not be “credited” against any personal injury award against the negligent driver.

High Point, United States - January 11, 2019 /PressCable/ —

In North Carolina personal injury law, there is a principle known as the “collateral source rule.” This rule basically states that a court cannot reduce a personal injury award to account for payments the plaintiff received from third-party sources. For example, if an insurance company pays a car accident victim’s medical bills, that payment cannot be used as evidence to reduce the negligent driver’s damages.

On December 7, 2018, the North Carolina Supreme Court held the collateral source rule also applies to uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM) benefits received by an accident victim. North Carolina law requires all insurers to offer UM coverage as part of their auto insurance policies. As the name suggests, UM coverage is designed to compensate policyholders when they are injured in an accident involving another driver who lacks sufficient insurance or assets to pay 100 percent of the damages.

In the case before the Supreme Court, Hairston v. Harward, the plaintiff and the defendant collided at an intersection in Lexington, N.C. The defendant had an auto insurance policy with a $100,000 liability limit. The plaintiff had his own policy through Erie Insurance Exchange that included $250,000 in UM coverage.

The plaintiff later sued the defendant, alleging the latter’s negligence caused the car accident. A jury agreed with the plaintiff and awarded $263,000 in damages. The judge reduced the award by $30,000 to account for other payments received by the plaintiff in connection with his injuries. But the plaintiff also received $145,000 from Erie under his UM policy. The defendant argued this amount should be taken off the damage award as well. In December 2015, the judge ruled the defendant was entitled to a “credit” for the UM payment.

The North Carolina Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s ruling, but the state Supreme Court reversed. Writing for the Supreme Court, Justice Sam J. Ervin IV said that the public policy reasons underlying the collateral source rule supported the plaintiff’s position: “A decision that a plaintiff must credit the payment that he or she receives as a result of the decision to purchase [UM] coverage against the judgment entered against the defendant whose negligence caused the plaintiff’s injuries strikes us as likely to discourage North Carolina citizens from purchasing uninsured motorist coverage, a result that would have obvious deleterious consequences.”

North Carolina personal injury attorney Bryant T. Aldridge Jr., said the Supreme Court’s ruling was a common-sense victory for accident victims. “Other state Supreme Courts have reached the same conclusion as North Carolina when confronted with the question of how to treat UM benefits under the collateral source rule. Although there is some risk of ‘double recovery’ by a plaintiff in personal injury cases, that is preferable to allowing negligent defendants to avoid paying their full share of damages.”

Aldridge added that UM carriers still have the the right of subrogation under North Carolina law. This means the insurance company can seek reimbursement of any amounts it paid to the insured victim out of any subsequent personal injury award. But in the Hairston case, the plaintiff’s UM insurer decided to waive its subrogation rights.

Contact Info:
Name: Bryant Aldridge
Email: Send Email
Organization: The McAllister Law Firm, PLLC
Address: 201 Neal Pl, High Point, NC 27262, United States
Phone: +1-336-882-4300

Source: PressCable

Release ID: 467542

Latest News

Patriots' Kraft to receive warm welcome in Israel

Jun 17, 2019

JERUSALEM — Israel is rolling out the red carpet for New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft, who arrives next week to collect the Genesis Prize, a prestigious award dubbed by its sponsors as the "Jewish Nobel Prize." The ceremony on June 20 would mark Kraft's highest-profile public appearance since he was charged in February with soliciting a prostitute at a Florida massage parlor. He has pleaded innocent. Kraft, a longtime supporter of Jewish and Israeli causes, can expect a warm welcome during a nearly weeklong visit. In addition to collecting the $1 million award, he is scheduled to have lunch...

Turkey's Erdogan witness in footballer Mesut Ozil's wedding

Jun 17, 2019

ISTANBUL — Turkey President Recep Tayyip Erdogan was in the wedding party as Arsenal midfielder Mesut Ozil tied the knot on Friday. State-run Anadolu news agency said Erdogan and his wife, Emine, were legal witnesses for Ozil, who married model, actress and former Miss Turkey Amine Gulse in Istanbul. Secular Turkish weddings require a witness each for the bride and groom. Ozil, a German player of Turkish descent, quit Germany's soccer team last year after he was criticized for posing for a photograph with Erdogan before the World Cup. In his international retirement announcement, Ozil accused the German football federation,...

Libyan commander hands over prominent militant to Egypt

Jun 17, 2019

CAIRO — A prominent Egyptian militant wanted for scores of terror attacks in his country was handed over to Egypt on Wednesday by Libyan forces loyal to a commander pushing to take the capital of Tripoli and flown to Cairo. Egyptian TV networks aired footage of a blindfolded Hisham el-Ashmawi, a former army officer turned militant, landing in Cairo and being taken off a military plane. El-Ashmawi was captured last October in the Libyan city of Derna, a longtime bastion of Islamic militants, by commander Khalifa Hifter's self-styled Libyan National Army. Hifter's forces now are battling to take Tripoli, fighting...

Ramadan in Mideast is for fasting and Facebook, data shows

Jun 17, 2019

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — The Muslim holy month of Ramadan, with its long days of fasting and prayer meant to draw worshippers closer to God and away from worldly distractions, is being reshaped by technology. People in the Middle East spend close to 58 million more hours on Facebook during Ramadan and watch more YouTube videos — everything from beauty tips and recipes to sports and TV dramas — than any other time of the year, making the holy month not only the most important one for Muslims, but also the prime time of the year for advertisers. For...

2 Libyan reporters taken by commander Hifter's forces freed

Jun 17, 2019

CAIRO — The U.N. mission in Libya says two local TV reporters detained by forces loyal to a commander who is on the offensive to capture the country's capital, Tripoli, have been released after three weeks in captivity. Libya's Alahrar TV station said commander Khalifa Hifter's self-styled Libyan National Army detained two of its journalists, Mohamed al-Qarg and Mohamed al-Shibani, earlier this month. The TV station, which backs the U.N.-supported government in Tripoli, said the journalists were released on Friday. The U.N. said late Saturday that it welcomed their "safe return to their families" in the western city of Zintan....

Search for something?

Sign up now!

In Hip N Trendy, we constantly discover and share the best products in the market to make sure that you know what’s new. It’s always FUN to talk with people who have the same interests as us, don’t you agree?

Contact us: sales[at]